I was going to title this post “Seven Genres I’ll Never Write”, but I decided that was unnecessarily rash. For one thing, I’ve been known to tackle a particular genre that feels alien just for the challenge of it. Also, I really don’t know how my tastes, or the market, will change. I don’t normally tend to be much influenced by the current trends or the latest hot selling themes, but it’s always possible that I’ll have a killer idea I just can’t resist.
So
here’s a list of the genres I haven’t tried yet. I won’t try to
predict the future.
Sports
romance
As I
noted in an earlier Saturday Seven post, I’m almost completely
uninterested in any sort of team or organized sports. The closest
I’ve come to a “sports” story was Crossed
Hearts, a MM tale set at a competitive Scrabble tournament.
Western
romance
For
some readers, and authors, cowboys have an enduring appeal, but they
generally leave me cold. I’m a born-and-bred Easterner, for one
thing. I’ve traveled through the American West, but I don’t know
it well and actually don’t feel that comfortable in those dusty,
arid, wide open spaces.
Then
there’s the smell. Whenever I try to imagine a sexy cowboy, I start
thinking about what he’d smell like after riding a horse all day,
or rounding up the cattle, or mucking out the barns... The question
of olfactory stimuli becomes particularly off-putting when I think
about historical Western tales. Back in the days of the Wild West,
baths were at best a monthly activity!
Zombie romance
Vampires,
yes. Shifters, sure. Ghosts, tentacled monsters, even Big Foot might
make their way into one of my stories. But zombies? As characters?
I’ve written a bit of erotic horror, but I can’t imagine how I
could make zombies appealing. Again, decomposing bodies are going to
reek, and bad smells put me in a very bad mood.
I guess
I could imagine writing a scifi romance set in the context of a
zombie apocalypse, though that’s been done so often I think I’d
be bored. I will say that I’d be deeply impressed by an author who
managed to create a sympathetic, non-disgusting zombie protagonist.
Secret
baby romance
I’ve
never written a pregnant heroine, let alone a classic (dare I use
that term?) secret baby romance. This is partly due to the fact that
I personally don’t have children (other than my fur babies) and
have never been pregnant. I came of age after the advent of the Pill,
so I’ve always had control of my fertility. I think the whole topic
is less central for me than for many women.
I
certainly can imagine writing a story where the conflict involved
pregnancy, but I haven’t done so yet.
In
fact, as far as I can recall, only two of my many heroines have
children, Ruby Jones in Wild
About That Thing, and Beatrice, the Victorian woman with the
secret life in my novel Miranda’s
Masks.
Regency
romance
I love
historical fiction. I love to read it, and I’d love to write more
of it than I do—though
to be honest I’m sometimes too lazy to do the research this would
require. Still, I’ve written a few historical tales, set in the
Middle Ages, in Elizabethan
times, in the Victorian period and in the
Gilded Age at the turn of the twentieth century. Somehow,
though, I’ve never had the slightest inclination to write a Regency
story, despite their popularity.
One
factor is my unfamiliarity with the period. However, I have to say
that in general, I have not found the Regencies I’ve read to be all
that interesting. I guess I prefer ordinary, everyday people to the
dukes and earls that seem to populate this sub-genre.
Military
romance
This is
another really popular sub-genre that doesn’t ring my bell at all.
I grew up during the Vietnam war, and I’m certain that colored my
view of the armed forces. Everyone I knew would do anything they
could to avoid military service.
Futanari
romance
In case you’re not familiar with the term, futanari
refers to individuals who have the sexual characteristics of both
genders. There’s a popular niche genre for erotica and erotic
romance featuring such characters. Sally Bend’s Bending
the Bookshelf blog reviews many of them.
I’ve never read any of this genre, let alone written
any. However, I’ll be frank; I’m tempted, if only because I
really like mixing things up in my stories.
So—let
me ask you, my readers: are there any of these genres that you’d
like
to see me try? Leave me a comment with your thoughts. I’ll
randomly draw the name of one reader who’ll receive his or her
choice of Crossed
Hearts or Wild
About That Thing.
By
the way, be sure to visit the other authors who have Saturday Seven
posts today. You’ll find the full list of links at Long andShort Reviews.
14 comments:
My thoughts on those genres are quite similar to yours. I think the Zombie romance could possibly be turned around into an undead romance. Not so much a rotting flesh type of zombie but more like pale skin and no heartbeat. I know the challenge would be to make the characters not seem like vampires. I think you could pull it off.
lringel at comcast dot net
I'd vote for Futa. From a guy's perspective, that would be erotic to watch!
Yeah, a zombie romance would be difficult to get right. I feel like the horror elements of that plot could easily overwhelm the romance, although I'm sure there are authors out there who figured out how to balance the two.
I agree with Larry. A Futanari romance would be interesting for sure.
My Saturday Seven post: http://lydiaschoch.com/saturday-seven-what-to-read-next-if-you-loved-the-handmaids-tale/
I'm with you on the zombie issue and am not fond of the secret baby. I haven't read Funtanari, it would be interesting to see if you could write a strory in the genre that I found romantic or hot.
There are genres I like among the listed, but if it is not your thing, stick with what works for you.
I think a Regency or military one would be intriguing. You cold give those genres some unique flavor.
I read a zombie series of books (one of the characters--the evil doctor who developed the virus, lol--is named after me) I loved everything about it... right up until the ending when the heroine has to kill her love interest because the shots that kept him from actually becoming a zombie stopped working. I have kept the books, but I'll never read them again. They weren't marketed as a romance, but I absolutely expected the author to find a way to give them a HEA. I imagine it's a tough row to hoe.
I hate secret baby romances with every fiber of my being...though I actually wrote one. Sort of. The heroine does everything she can to find and get in touch with the hero to tell him, but isn't able to. I can't ever think of a reason, short of psychosis, to keep a father from knowing his child.
Thanks for visiting me earlier. I'm here if any one else would like to: http://www.mariannearkins.com/saturday-seven-my-tbr-list/
Hi, I love Regency Romance. Maybe this time you could have the hero coming back from war with a challenge. Needs to marry quickly because of the will but also needs to get his act together and learn to be able to do things again.
I salute you for knowing your strengths and concentrating on them. One of the reasons I don't offer to edit historicals is because I am afraid I would miss glaring anachronisms, lol. I'm definitely NOT fond of zombies...in romances or other genres, and dystopic romances tend to depress me. I think you probably know enough about exotic locales to pen a fascinating romantic suspense!
My Saturday Seven is here: https://thereadingaddict-elf.blogspot.com/2018/05/saturday-seven-favorite-young-adult.html
any kind
bn100candg at hotmail dot com
Because I could never choose, how about a futanari sports romance? I don't know if it's been done...
--Trix, vitajex(at)aol(Dot)com
I agree, I do not like to imagine zombies in romantic scenes. But cowboys can still work, maybe after their bath time or during bath time, lol.
I'm not an author just a reader so the choices in writing across the spectrum or reading what's available amounts to comfortability. Choices in genre as I weave in and out of SF vsromancevsChristian fiction etc makes the joys of reading for me. Its my choice based on my dollars and my diving into new authors different genres etc. So I imagine writers feel the same of genre comfortability and to take the faith leap into unknown territory must be scary and hope it sells.Because it's a living for u the author and pure enjoyment for us The reader.
Congratulations to Anne, who's the winner of the drawing. You didn't leave an email address, so please get in touch with me (lisabet at lisabetsarai dot com) and let me know which book you prefer.
Thanks to everyone who left their comments and suggestions. I have lots to think about!
Post a Comment
Let me know your thoughts! (And if you're having trouble commenting, try enabling third-party cookies in your browser...)